A reader writes:
Is it badmouthing an employer if it’s the fact?
I’ve labored at my present job for nearly 15 years. My boss is an legal professional in a solo apply. He’s planning to retire on the finish of this 12 months. Prior to now 5 years, he has gone from 5 staff to at least one because the apply winds down. I used to be planning to stick with him till the top, transitioning to part-time and utilizing that as a step down towards early retirement or a kind of sabbatical earlier than returning to full-time work. He pushed to have me go right down to 4 days after Thanksgiving, regardless that the workload was not fairly prepared for that. Since I used to be now part-time, there was no Christmas bonus and I used to be not going to accrue anymore PTO. I advised him I used to be high quality with that so long as I might use my accrued trip time and sick days. I’ve 4 weeks of accrued PTO and figured I might not use all of it earlier than the agency shut down anyway. He has now revoked my accrued PTO and expects me to work with no trip or sick days in any respect.
I’m at present job looking. I don’t wish to stroll out as a result of I don’t need him to have the ability to use that towards me in a reference. The final paralegal/workplace supervisor left over a 12 months in the past, and he has completed nothing however badmouth her regardless that she was an excellent worker and had been with him for over 20 years. I’ve been right here for thus lengthy that the attorneys and workplace supervisor I labored for at my earlier job are retired. I believe I might win a labor board dispute regardless that I reside in a really employer-friendly state. However I don’t wish to struggle, I simply need out.
I do know you aren’t purported to badmouth an employer in job interviews, however what if the very fact is that he stole from me? Can I say calmly that he revoked my accrued PTO and I made a decision to search for one other job?
You can, however there’s no must when you’ve got a a lot much less dramatic rationalization for why you’re leaving: your boss is winding down the agency so he can retire.
As a common rule when interviewers ask why you’re leaving your present job, it’s higher to keep away from solutions about disagreements or drama, even whenever you’re not the supply of them. There’s all the time an opportunity that they’re going to surprise if there’s extra to the story or when you’re deciphering it in essentially the most inflammatory method. However even when it’s clear that’s not the case, you need them to recollect you because the candidate with the spectacular abilities in X, not the one who was screwed over by an unbelievable jerk of a boss.
In your specific case, the reply you proposed — that your boss took again your accrued PTO — isn’t all that far towards the drama finish of the spectrum. You can cite it when you needed to. However there’s no level in utilizing it when you’ve got such a straightforward, bland, completely unremarkable reply proper there for the taking. You’ve been there 15 years, he’s closing down the agency, completed.
Actually, everytime you’ve been at your present job for no less than a number of years, you possibly can simply cite that — “I’ve been right here X years and I’ve loved the work, however now I’m able to tackle one thing new.” That’s nearly all the time preferable to explaining that your employer sucks, even when they do. Bland and straightforward is simply all the time a better option for this query, so long as it’s believable.
There are occasions when it received’t be believable, although. For instance, when you’ve solely been within the job for 5 months, you possibly can’t say you’re able to tackle one thing new (no less than not with out trying extraordinarily flighty). In instances like that, search for essentially the most impartial, low-drama technique to clarify the scenario. “They introduced me on to do X nevertheless it seems they really want Y” is ok to say when it’s true. So is “We’ve had plenty of turnover and I’m on the lookout for someplace extra secure” or “My staff commonly works 60-hour weeks” or “I’m on the lookout for one thing with extra predictable hours” or “Price range cuts have me involved concerning the stability of my division.”
You talked about you had been apprehensive about badmouthing your outdated employer, however that conference is extra about subjective assertions — like “my boss was a nightmare,” “the management was in chaos,” “the tradition was poisonous,” and so on. Since your interviewer doesn’t know you properly, they received’t know in case your evaluation is dependable or when you’re simply tough/dramatic/have unhealthy judgment. However that doesn’t imply you possibly can’t share a fast, goal truth to elucidate why you left/are trying.
Additionally, typically an excellent reply might be, “I’m not actively trying, however I noticed this job and was actually due to X.” So that you’re speaking about what’s drawing you towards the brand new job fairly than away from the outdated one.
However go for bland and unmemorable every time you possibly can (simply don’t be obscure to the purpose of meaningless).